Skip to main content
Neil Butler

Neil Butler

Team Leader • Complaints Operations • Quality & Risk • Service Delivery • Customer Experience

Talent
ManchesterMember since March 24, 2026
FCA DISPConsumer DutyFOSPower BIAptean Respond
·

Hire this person

Send a job offer directly to this candidate

FCA DISPConsumer DutyFOSPower BIAptean Respond

About

Experienced operational and complaints leader with 33 years across customer operations, complaints, and people leadership, progressing from Insurance Clerk to Complaints Operations Manager through continuous internal promotion. Strong track record improving quality, workflow stability, customer outcomes, and team capability within regulated environments, including adapting to mergers, acquisitions, and organisational change. Following voluntary redundancy in February 2026 amid organisational restructuring, now focused on Team Leader roles in Complaints Operations, Service Delivery, Quality & Risk, and Customer Experience.

Experience

Complaints Operations Manager (Extended Secondment) at Atlanta Group / Markerstudy Retail (2024-01 – 2025-09)

Led complaints operations across merged brands during a period of high change and platform migration.

  • Seconded to lead a 25-person complaints taskforce; in June 2025, selected for progression into the permanent Complaints Operations Manager role, but appointment was prevented by a group-wide recruitment freeze. Returned to the substantive Complaints Manager role in Sept 2025 during organisational restructuring, and subsequently accepted voluntary redundancy in February 2026.
  • Assumed the combined remit of one Operations Manager and two Complaints Managers (roles that normally cover 14 staff) and led the expanded 25-person taskforce alone, sustaining SLAs, governance and delivery through sustained change.
  • Rapidly upskilled an inexperienced, high-risk team through intensive coaching and capability reviews, lifting overall performance standards across the group.
  • Increased overall team productivity from 83% to 123% and improved decision quality from 73% to 95% by establishing new triage, allocation, and calibration workflows.
  • Introduced a standardised QA calibration framework across merged brand teams, eliminating decision variances and ensuring uniform application of FCA DISP rules.
  • Designed and embedded dynamic capacity planning models and daily resource allocation tools across 25 analysts, enabling the taskforce to absorb volume surges without breaching regulatory SLAs.
  • Cleared a backlog of 90 high-priority complex cases within five days while delivering 1,400+ monthly case allocations.
  • Used Power BI dashboards and Aptean Respond data to provide real-time reporting on queue backlogs, capacity, and SLA performance directly to the executive team.

Complaints Manager at Atlanta Group / Markerstudy Retail (2020-01 – 2026-02)

  • Directed a team of 7 Complaints Associates handling complex escalations, CEO-level complaints, SARs, and vulnerable customer cases in line with FCA DISP requirements.
  • Reduced team absenteeism by 70% over two years through early intervention and consistent leadership.
  • Provided daily leadership, case allocation, and coaching to sustain service levels and decision quality during high-volume periods.
  • Established enhanced Vulnerable Customer protocols and coaching frameworks, ensuring early identification and fair outcomes under FCA Consumer Duty.
  • Promoted inclusive leadership through fair decision-making, transparent coaching and consistent support for colleagues from merged brands, reinforced by Open University training in Diversity & Inclusion (2026).
  • Analysed complaint root causes across operations to share actionable insight, driving category complaint reductions of up to 60%.
  • Supported colleagues through platform migrations and process updates, maintaining operational control and decision consistency through transition periods.
  • Oversaw end-to-end complaint logging, tracking, and SLA monitoring within Aptean Respond, ensuring operational control across multi-brand platform migrations.
  • Collated monthly MI for FCA RMAR preparation, strengthening governance controls and regulatory alignment.

Technical Manager at Swinton Insurance / Atlanta Group (2010-01 – 2020-12)

  • Led investigations into high-value Professional Indemnity (PI) claims involving allegations of negligence, achieving a personal FOS overturn rate below 5% compared with a 22% departmental average.
  • Provided senior technical guidance, case audits, and practical coaching to Complaints Managers and Associates, strengthening decision consistency and regulatory compliance.
  • Independently built an audit-ready, FCA-compliant claims register and process workflows from scratch following an unplanned loss of handover support, establishing robust financial oversight and tracking for high-risk claims.
  • Prepared case files, drafted MG11 witness statements, and provided court representation on policy interpretation and liability disputes.
  • Coordinated multi-agency fraud investigations with Police and DWP, overseeing financial and customer risk across high-risk, multi-agency cases.

Branch Manager (Keighley) & Complaints Associate (Manchester) at Colonnade / Swinton Insurance (2000-01 – 2010-12)

  • Led multi-site branch operations and stepped up as Area Manager across 9 sites; turned around a loss-making branch to increase margin from 12% to 28% and renewal retention from 31% to 88%.
  • Selected as a pilot site for new MoneyGram services following sustained branch improvements and operational stability.
  • Handled the operational impact of Drake Insurance entering insolvency during week one as Branch Manager; protected 70 affected customers while re-engaging staff, turning around what had been a negative work environment before joining, and improving baseline sales metrics.
  • Investigated complex complaints, reviewed evidence under DISP rules, and supported cross-functional root-cause reduction projects.

Assistant Manager / Insurance Clerk at Colonnade Insurance / Insurance Matters Ltd (1993-01 – 2000-12)

Progressive roles including Assistant Manager and Insurance Clerk across Colonnade Insurance and Insurance Matters Ltd. Started career doing manual underwriting with rating tables before the shift to computerised pricing, building foundational operations experience.

Career Break (2026-02 – Present)

Following voluntary redundancy as part of organisational restructuring, completed further professional development (Open University: Difference & Challenge in Teams, Commercial Awareness, Diversity & Inclusion in the Workplace). Now focused on Team Leader opportunities across Complaints Operations, Service Delivery, Quality & Risk, and Customer Experience.

Education

Difference and Challenge in Teams; Commercial Awareness; Diversity and Inclusion in the Workplace – Open University (2026-01 – 2026-12)

Management Development Programme in Take the Lead (2024-01 – 2024-12)

Course in Writing an Exceptional Statement of Evidence with Helen Swaffield, Barrister – MBL Law (2014-01 – 2014-12)

Certificate in Certificate of Insurance Practice (CIP) & Certificate of Insurance Proficiency (COP) – Chartered Insurance Institute

NVQ Level 3 in Customer Service – RSA

NVQ Level 2 in Insurance – RSA

BTEC National Diploma in Business and Finance – Oldham College

GCSE in 8 GCSEs (Grades A–C including Maths & English) – Royton and Crompton Comprehensive

Skills

Team LeaderComplaints OperationsQuality & RiskService DeliveryCustomer Experience

Reviews